I grew up in a two-ply family. The constant bombardment of advertisements extolling the virtues of "quilted" tissue that were thrust upon my father and grandparents during their daily TV game shows paid off in extraordinary fashion. Charmin was the brand of choice, as far as I remember, but any brand that was on sale was usually purchased. I remember watching those ads as a child (similar ads run to this day) and thinking to myself, "Gee, if two-ply tissue cannot keep my hand clean, who in hell would want to try one-ply?" And that was with the obligatory bunching-up of the tissue into a seemingly sanitary barrier betwixt my hand and the target. Of course, no one ever saw an ad for one-ply tissue, or if they did, there most certainly was no mention of the missing ply. My only encounters with the single ply variety were in commercial restrooms, on those rare occasions when I actually decided that I could not wait until I got home. My most memorable one-ply experience was in the American Legion in Gainesville. Being only nine years old at the time, I thought that the reason I could only get three sheets out at once was due to the inferiority of the ply-less product. It did not occur to me that the tissue there was more expensive than the good-ol' wipe back home, and that the dispenser was designed to keep the tube from spinning freely in order to encourage conservative use. I finally got about 30 sheets out, just in case. They were extremely thin, you see. A remarkable thing happened then. I did my business once, obtained more paper, and the second time it came back clean. Absolutely white. Of course, the insides of my cheeks were sore from the abrasion of the paper (you cannot quilt one-ply), and it felt clean, but it was impossible to think that I got everything in one shot. I left the restroom, still unimpressed with the unquilted wipe.
Have you ever noticed that two-ply leaves little paper twisties hanging between your cheeks? The upper ply tears back and twists up, sticking to whatever started the tearing. Most two-ply also relies on the target to stick to it, rather than scraping it off. The scraping part is contrary to soft tissue, I suppose. When the target sticks but does not lift up, which is most of the time, the available surface area of the tissue is minimized, or you get your hands dirty, or both, and thus must wipe again. But, damn if your butt cheeks don't feel baby soft after all that wiping.
I was first introduced to good consumer-packaged one-ply at a local Sam's Club store. In their restrooms they used an off-brand tissue that was sold in the store. It was not very thin like most one-ply you would find in a commercial restroom, and it worked just as well as the first one-ply wipe I used back in the day. I bought the 50-roll pack for $14 and never looked back. It occured to me that day that if you're going to bunch up a wad of tissue to wipe anyway (seriously, who wipes with just a few squares? I personally will not attempt it without 10-15 squares, if not more) then do you really need two-ply tissue? With the one-ply, you get twice as many squares which, when bunched-up, are more absorbent and effective than two-ply, albeit not as soft. And no more paper dingleberries. Also, once you've been using it for a few weeks, the abrasiveness is not as bad. Scott makes a softer version for a little more money, but still much cheaper than any decent two-ply.
So, save a tree, save money, stay clean, and develop tough ass-cheeks. Use one-ply.
Have you ever noticed that two-ply leaves little paper twisties hanging between your cheeks? The upper ply tears back and twists up, sticking to whatever started the tearing. Most two-ply also relies on the target to stick to it, rather than scraping it off. The scraping part is contrary to soft tissue, I suppose. When the target sticks but does not lift up, which is most of the time, the available surface area of the tissue is minimized, or you get your hands dirty, or both, and thus must wipe again. But, damn if your butt cheeks don't feel baby soft after all that wiping.
I was first introduced to good consumer-packaged one-ply at a local Sam's Club store. In their restrooms they used an off-brand tissue that was sold in the store. It was not very thin like most one-ply you would find in a commercial restroom, and it worked just as well as the first one-ply wipe I used back in the day. I bought the 50-roll pack for $14 and never looked back. It occured to me that day that if you're going to bunch up a wad of tissue to wipe anyway (seriously, who wipes with just a few squares? I personally will not attempt it without 10-15 squares, if not more) then do you really need two-ply tissue? With the one-ply, you get twice as many squares which, when bunched-up, are more absorbent and effective than two-ply, albeit not as soft. And no more paper dingleberries. Also, once you've been using it for a few weeks, the abrasiveness is not as bad. Scott makes a softer version for a little more money, but still much cheaper than any decent two-ply.
So, save a tree, save money, stay clean, and develop tough ass-cheeks. Use one-ply.